Logistics experts are warning that plans to expand passenger services on the West London Orbital (WLO) – welcome as they are - must also protect vital rail freight traffic, balancing improved passenger connectivity across west and north-west London with the needs of the wider freight network and the UK economy.
Specialists at The Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport (CILT UK) welcome the potential benefits of the proposed WLO passenger expansion plans, especially to disadvantaged areas like Harlesden which would gain improved access to London's wider transport network. However, the Institute is clear that TfL’s proposals do not demonstrate how existing and future freight rail services will be protected from the effects of adding more passenger trains to the West London rail network.
The proposals would double passenger services through Acton Wells Junction from eight to 16 trains per hour. This is a key location for freight movements right across London and for the wider South-East. Acton Wells Junction already handles around 72 freight trains a day, many of them carrying construction materials, with significant growth in freight traffic expected as London's housing and infrastructure programmes expand.
Julian Worth FCILT, a member of the CILT(UK) Strategic Rail Policy Group, explained: “Creating a West London Orbital route for passenger trains is an excellent notion and something we support. But this needs to be balanced against the nation’s wider goals. Acton Wells is key to transporting limestone from quarries in Somerset, Gloucestershire and South Wales, and other construction materials such as sand and gravel needed to support housebuilding and development across London and the South-East. Rail freight already delivers around 50% of London’s construction materials and this is set to grow substantially.”
The West London rail network also carries container trains serving London Gateway and Tilbury, whose growing importance to the UK's international trade and distribution networks will generate additional demand for rail freight capacity.
Julian added: “Simply increasing the number of tracks at Acton Wells from two to four will not resolve the underlying conflict between passenger and freight trains, many of which need to cross each other's paths. The Institute believes that grade separation, or another engineering solution capable of removing these conflicts, is likely to be necessary to accommodate the proposed passenger service alongside existing and future freight requirements. The bottom line is that passenger connectivity and strategic freight must go hand in hand and not marginalise one at the expense of the other.”

CILT (UK) sets out recommendations in its formal consultation response. It recommends that TfL pause further development of its current proposals until a comprehensive capacity and operational assessment has been undertaken jointly with Network Rail and informed by freight operators and customers, taking account of future growth in freight traffic.
CILT (UK) strongly supports improvements to urban passenger transport. However, the Institute believes that these responsibilities must also extend to supporting the strategic freight and logistics infrastructure on which regional economies, national supply chains and major projects depend.
Julian concluded: “Acton Wells Junction is not simply a piece of local railway that could be used more. It is a nationally important freight location, and the implications of introducing additional passenger services must be considered in wider context.
“This is not a choice between passengers and freight - it is about delivering both together. The Mayor and TfL have an opportunity to demonstrate that London's transport investment can improve local connectivity while strengthening the strategic freight infrastructure that supports London's growth and the wider UK economy.”
The assessment should establish how the proposed passenger service can be accommodated alongside current freight operations and forecast growth, including demand from London Gateway, the development of Barking Eurohub, international rail freight through the Channel Tunnel and, crucially, the construction materials required for London's housing and infrastructure programmes.
The Institute says that only with a credible solution to Acton Wells Junction can the WLO proposals be considered a viable enhancement to London's transport network. CILT (UK) believes the outcome should be a railway that delivers improved passenger connectivity while also protecting and enhancing the freight capacity essential to London's prosperity and the UK's economic growth.
The Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport UK (CILT(UK)) is the professional body representing professionals across logistics, supply chain and transport.
You can read the full consultation response by CILT (UK) here.